Some different ways to perform a Kata
There are three pillars to studying traditional Karate: Kihon, Kumite and Kata. They teach different aspects of the art and so complement each other, but each one of us will have its favourites. For me, it is Kata, which is where we can most readily identify the differences between fighting styles. In a sense, the different Kata make up the soul of Karate (or of Shotokan, or any other traditional Asian martial art).
That said, if Kata is so important, is there a better way to perform it? Should we all try to emulate what sports Karateka do in competitions? Should we instead try to execute each technique with perfect form, but perhaps less strength? Or else, the whole Kata with perfect fluency, but perhaps less form definition? Or take each step and movement with strength and speed, but in isolation from the next or the previous one?
At the…



Interesting concept and notes that I had never thought about. For the view in favour of loud breathing, I am reminded of the fear effect a loud scream can cause in an adversary. Also, from experience, the release associated to a loud scream can make you feel less restrained in applying more power to your techniques.
And on a very different note, how does this relate to the remarkably audible breathing in Sanchin kata of Goju-ryu and others?